Dark Web: Tor's co-creator defends the anonymity tool Dark Web: Tor's co-creator defends the anonymity tool Pinterest

Dark Web: Tor's co-creator defends the anonymity tool

Button Policing: in layman's terms, Tor hides your identity by pinging your connection around many different servers across the world, making your actual location extremely hard to track.



When Roger Dingledine talks about the dark web, he waves his hands in the air - as if not quite convinced of its existence.

I give him the benefit of the doubt - his arguably blasé attitude, I think, is a symptom of being consistently called upon to defend his creation.

He is the co-creator of Tor, the most popular software available for gaining access to the part of the internet unreachable using a conventional browser - including what is often referred to as the dark or underground web.

To some, Tor is a menace: a (largely) impenetrable system that enables some of the most depraved crimes to take place on the internet.

To others, it is a lifeline, the only way to safely access the online services that most of us take for granted.

Dingledine would rather we talked about the latter. The scale of the dark web - with its drug deals, weapons sales and child abuse imagery - is insignificant when considered in the bigger picture, he argues.

But we must talk about the former. I meet Dingledine at this year's Def Con, the large underground hacking convention held in Las Vegas.

The timing was ideal - the event came just over a week after the closure of two huge dark web marketplaces. The biggest, Alphabay, was said to boast more than 200,000 users and $1bn (£0.7bn) a year in revenue.

Roger Dingledine
Image captionRoger Dingledine is an MIT-trained computer scientist

Dingledine's talk was the day prior to our meeting, and in it he criticised misinformed journalists for sensationalising the size and scale of the dark web.

"I think a lot of it comes down to incentive mismatches," he tells me, "where journalists have to create more controversy and get something so that everybody will want to read their article.

"The story is privacy is under threat around the world, and that's been the story for a while - so they need a new story."


The Tor Project's website has a section called "Abuse FAQ".

It is here the group attempts to address the most controversial side of Tor use: that it is an enabler of criminals intent on carrying out the most shocking and sickening crimes.

When talking about this, Dingledine invokes the "guns don't kill people" defence. Tor does not commit crime, he says, criminals do.

"I would say that there are bad people on the internet and they're doing bad things, but Tor does not enable them to do the bad things.

Media captionThis animation shows you the layers of the internet - and the dark web.

"It's not like there's a new set of bad people in the world who exist because Tor exists."

I guess not. But I suggest that Tor indisputably provides a way in which a novice can make themselves essentially untraceable online.

"I still think that most of the bad stuff on the internet has nothing to do with Tor," Dingledine insists.

"Most of the bad stuff on the internet is due to huge criminal organisations. There's a lot of crime out there."

Click button policing

In layman's terms, Tor hides your identity by pinging your connection around many different servers across the world, making your actual location extremely hard to track.

There have been rumours that law enforcement has "cracked" Tor but, aside from isolated vulnerabilities, Dingledine says the concept remains solid.

"As far as I know, no, they haven't [cracked Tor].

"Tor is the best option there is out there, but that doesn't mean Tor is perfect. No software is perfect."

Any major busts and arrests have been traced back to human error - good old, old-fashioned policing.

"Which is frustrating," Dingledine interjects, "Because the modern police world wants to just click a button and have the bad guy show up. Old-fashioned police work is hard, takes energy."

Media captionJeff Sessions highlighted the significant quantities of illegal drugs traded via the dark web

Tor was mentioned in the documents leaked as part of Edward Snowden's whistleblowing in 2014. Under the delicate heading "Tor Stinks… but it could be worse", the National Security Agency (NSA) noted: "We will never be able to de-anonymise all Tor users all the time."

Given this, you would think the US (and others) would be taking every step to weaken Tor. Ban it, even. But in fact, the US government has done more than any other to keep it alive - donating several million dollars to Dingledine and team since the project's inception in the nineties.

He is confident that funding will continue.

"A lot of the US government funding for internet freedom tools comes from Republicans. The current congress is quite supportive of giving people tools to keep people safer on the internet."

The reason? The FBI, CIA, military and others all value anonymity too. In their ideal world, Tor would exist, but they would hold a secret key to break in.

Good uses

In 2014, Facebook's London team announced it had set up a way for users to access Facebook through Tor. More than a million people use the site in this way every month.

Cyber attack graphic
Image copyrightGETTY IMAGES

"About 97% of Tor traffic has to do with people going to Facebook, and Wikipedia, and BBC, and ordinary websites on the internet, and they want to go there more safely," Dingledine says.

"Whereas 3% of the traffic has to do with this 'dark web' thing…. I have to wave my hands when I say the phrase."

The ability to access social networks anonymously is invaluable to people living in oppressive regimes or countries with high levels of surveillance around what citizens do online.

But given the majority of users can be found in the US and Europe - in places not typically considered to be oppressive - I argued that Tor's justification hinging on the needs of activists perhaps seems less than convincing.

"I think the line is getting a lot more blurry between the free countries, and the un-free countries," he says.


Shared from: BBC

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter all the required information, indicated by an asterisk (*). HTML code is not allowed.

back to top


Boldstart Founder Launches Hyperledger Fabric's First Blockchain Accelerator

The founder of VC firm Boldstart Ventures is launching the first accelerator dedicated exclusively to startups building on the Hyperledger Fabric blockchain.

CNN launches daily news show on Snapchat

CNN on Monday began streaming "The Update," a daily show on Snapchat featuring at least five news stories each episode from reporters and bureaus around the world, to attract younger viewers.

Quora now launches retargeting for advertisers

Quora’s newly launched ads platform now supports retargeting ads on the question-and-answer network.

Facebook faces scare that teens are going to Snapchat and Instagram. Again.

 Now playing on the internet: the episode in which everyone freaks out that young people are abandoning Facebook in favor of hot new social media services like Snap and Instagram.

IBM partners with Walmart, Unilever, Nestlé, and other food giants, to apply blockchain tech to food supply chains

They will be aiming to use blockchains to maintain secure digital records and improve the traceability of their foodstuffs

Blockchain can make social networks more private — and profitable for you

Fact: You’re going to spend a total of five years of your life on social media. But- is blockchain answer to everything?

The HuffPost’s tabloid-style homepage is paying dividends

The move was designed to deliver what Polgreen described as “a visceral snapshot of the day.”

Dashbot’s codeless Twitter Integration is now live!

Integrate your DM bot without code and in 10 seconds.

50 Bitcoin Exchanges Have Filed with the Japanese Financial Authority

In April, the Japanese government amended its fund settlement law to recognize bitcoin as a legal means of payment

Billionaire Calvin Ayre Acquires Crypto Media Outlet Coingeek

  The plan is for Calvinayre.com to continue to cover Bitcoin news as it relates to the gaming industry

Asus Debuts Specialized Motherboard for Cryptocurrency Miners

"Cryptocurrency and blockchain are here to stay"

Chatbot That Helps Users Appeal Parking Tickets Comes To U.S.

A chatbot called DoNotPay that helps users appeal parking tickets for free in the U.K. is now available in the United States.

How TD Ameritrade tackles security in Facebook Messenger chatbot

Chatbot is designed to answer faster than a human could.

How Blockchain Is Monetizing User’s Experience and Skills

Generating value is the key concept sustaining the explosion of Blockchain offerings in 2017.

Bezos on Amazon’s AI and Machine Learning Strategy

[It's all about] enabling other organizations to leverage the game-changer that is machine learning.

Mongolia's Hottest New Social App Is All About Horses

Although cowboy culture is mostly nostalgia in the United States these days, many rural Mongolians still rely on their horses in daily life. In Mongolia, horsemanship is one of the most celebrated aspects of their culture, even on social media. "If we...

Startups could be key to fixing tech's diversity problem

Silicon Valley companies are learning a hard lesson: They can't escape their attitude problems.

Android Oreo released by Google

Google has released the latest version of its Android mobile operating system (OS), which will be named after Oreo chocolate biscuits.

How RBC is using a blockchain to overhaul its loyalty program

“We see loyalty as a great use case for blockchain to allow us to provide customers more real-time access to rewards points to provide an almost Starbucks-like experience.”

Why finance brands are so hot on content marketing

Content is one way to make people return to their site to see new updates, buy new products and invest more money.

Reddit now allows users to upload videos

Videos are coming to Reddit, thanks to a new feature that allows users to upload video clips directly to the service.

Sharp sues Hisense over a foreign “gag order”

Sharp, a Japanese electronics manufacturer, has filed a lawsuit challenging a foreign gag order that company lawyers say prevents Sharp from talking about its own brand.

How A Police Body Camera Company Is Becoming An Artificial Intelligence Company

Like most technology companies today, Axon’s goal is to collect data; the free body camera trial is just another avenue to generate and collect more of it.

Mic Lays Off Dozens Just a Week After Promising Not To

A number of online outlets, including Mashable, Vice, and MTV News, have recently slashed their writing staffs to focus on producing visual content

Kit Kat accused of copying Atari game

Kit Kat's maker Nestle has been accused of copying Breakout, the 1970s computer game, in a marketing campaign.

YouTube TV expands to 14 new markets

YouTube is broadening access to live TV streaming as younger viewers increasingly watch shows online and traditional broadcast networks grapple with aging demographics among viewers.

Hyundai looks to build a >300-mile-range electric car

More carmakers are looking toward electric vehicles as fuel cell falters

Why Bancor Wants To Become The YouTube Of Cryptocurrency

If Bancor overcomes the initial scandals (it shortchanges its users' by rounding token values) Bancor could reshape the cryptocurrency marketplace as we know it.

The best of Siri: 11 funny responses from the iPhone's virtual assistant

Since its launch in 2011, Siri has become increasingly intelligent, and can now hold basic two-way conversations with users.

How Yogscast built a media empire

The newer generation doesn’t want to be told how to do things, they want to see it.

Skype’s new look arrives on the desktop in preview form

The chat-focused update comes with new features for messaging and calls.

Subscribe to the Business Brief Newsletter

Get our complimentary briefing, featuring news & analysis of the business trends and practices.
Terms and Conditions